At the McDonald’s I visit, there’s almost always a line at the drive-through order station. Whatever else the employees may be wondering, I doubt it’s whether a customer is coming.
That line makes me think about a case study we worked on when I was in business school in the 1980s. We were looking at the placement of annunciators in fast-food drive-through lanes.
An annunciator sounds like something you would need an MBA to understand. In this case, its job was simple: let the staff know a car had arrived.
In the arrangement we were studying, someone might be working elsewhere in the restaurant when a customer pulled in. The signal had to give that employee enough time to hear it and get to the window to take the order. Where along the approach should a car trigger the bell?
Too close to the window, and the customer would arrive before the employee. Too far away, and the employee would leave another task to stand at an empty window. There were studies of the most effective placement. A few seconds, multiplied by enough customers, became a business problem worth analyzing.
Of all the things to stay with me from business school, a bell announcing a potential hamburger buyer has proved surprisingly durable.
I think part of its appeal was how concrete the problem was. You could picture the car, the employee, the distance between them. Technology could help, but somebody still had to hear the signal and walk across the restaurant.
Now I look at the drive-through and see a different arrangement. The window at my McDonald’s seems to be staffed whenever I visit. Customers wait at the order station, place their orders, and move toward the windows. There’s a steady flow of people to serve.
The setup in that old case feels very far away.
When I looked into the technology, though, I found that the annunciator has descendants still at work. Modern drive-through systems can sound an arrival tone in an employee’s headset when a vehicle reaches a detection point. Sensors can include loops embedded in the pavement. Somewhere inside all the equipment, the message is still: somebody’s here. hme.com
The newer systems can do considerably more. HME, a supplier of drive-through equipment, offers camera-based technology that follows vehicles through the lane, measures their waiting time, and helps identify where service is slowing down. It can include the queue before the order station and the spaces where customers are asked to pull forward and wait for their food. HME
McDonald’s has taken advance warning a step further with a system called Ready on Arrival. In an update on its rollout, the company describes using geofencing—a virtual boundary around a location—to alert the crew to start preparing a mobile order as the customer approaches the restaurant. corporate.mcdonalds.com
Our business-school employee needed time to get to the window. A restaurant using that newer system can begin responding before the customer reaches the property.
I find that progression fascinating, partly because I experienced most of it without paying much attention.
I couldn’t tell you when I first encountered a drive-through camera. Or when I stopped being surprised that an order could appear on a screen for me to check. Somewhere along the way, those things became part of getting lunch.
We tend to remember technological change through the things we deliberately acquire. We buy a computer or a phone. We learn to use a new program. There’s a purchase, a learning period, perhaps some swearing.
Changes in the places we visit slip into our routines more quietly. The menu becomes a screen. The person taking the order wears a headset. Eventually, the restaurant may have a way to know we’re approaching. We adapt a little at a time, until an old memory reminds us how differently the same errand once worked.
There’s something useful in that for anyone who has ever worked through a business case. The problem comes with assumptions: how the employees spend their time, how customers behave, what information is available. Those assumptions can be perfectly sensible when you study them. Forty years later, you may need to explain the whole arrangement before anyone understands why finding the right place for a bell mattered.
I’m glad we studied it. Someone had to think about those few seconds and the person who needed them. The systems have grown more elaborate, but they still depend on getting useful information to someone in time to act.
At my McDonald’s, meanwhile, the line keeps forming. Whatever technology is keeping track of us, I still have to wait my turn. But I remember when just knowing a car had arrived was a problem worth taking to business school.






